How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza: Top 5 Ways

Little Caesars is a successful pizza chain in the U.S. where you will find all types of pizza, from deep dish to ultimate supreme. Whoever has had their pizza knows how delicious it is.

Little Caesars has other great food besides pizza. They are also very convenient because you can just grab and go if you’re in a hurry. And another best part is here you can customize your own pizza? Feels like a dream, right?

For these reasons, sometimes, you buy more pizza than needed and are left with leftovers. What do you do? Store it in the box in the fridge? This is a mistake everyone makes, making it harder to reheat. No problem! Just follow our article and learn how to reheat Little Caesars pizza correctly.

Table of Contents show

Step-by-Step Instructions for Reheating Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars’ high-quality ingredients, delicious dough recipes, vast pizza toppings, and crust types make them one of the leading pizza chains. Their pizza will taste great even when left in the fridge in the pizza box. But it is not a good idea.

You must store your leftover pizza properly; otherwise, it can get soggy and grow bacteria. You can get airtight containers or a plate and plastic wrap for proper storage.

If you are using airtight containers, ensure no moisture is inside. Take the pizza slices out of the box and put them in the airtight containers. You can now keep them in the fridge or freeze them.
If you are using plates and plastic wrap, then stack the pizza slices and use the plastic wrap to wrap the whole thing tightly with the plate. Make sure there is no air inside. Now, you can choose to keep them in the fridge or freeze them.

If you keep your pizza in the fridge, it will last for 2 to 3 days. On the other hand, if you choose to freeze them, they will last over a month. But, we think no fast food should be kept uneaten for that long.

Moreover, you must check if the pizza has gone bad before reheating. If you notice any fungus growing or change of color and odor, throw it out; your food has gone bad.

Now that the proper storage idea is clear, let’s move on to reheating.

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza in the Oven

Reheating Little Caesars pizza using the oven is easy and leaves you with crispy, hot pizza every time.

Defrost your pizza for an hour to avoid any cold spots.
At 350 degrees Fahrenheit, preheat the oven for 10 minutes.
If you have a pizza stone, you can also preheat it beforehand in the oven. But if you don’t, the oven pan will work just fine.
Take out the pizza stone or oven pan carefully. Make sure to wear oven mittens or gloves not to burn yourself.
Put the pizza on the pizza stone or the pan.
Set the timer for ten minutes.
After ten minutes, give it a minute or two to get crispy.
Take it out and serve it hot with your favorite sauce.

Reheat Your Leftover Caesars Pizza in the Toaster Oven

A toaster oven is your go-to kitchen appliance if you just want to snack on a slice or two. It works like a regular oven, but it won’t be able to fit a whole pizza. Toaster ovens work best for single or double pizza slices.

Preheat the toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit for a crispy crust.
Put the pan in the oven also to preheat.
Once it is heated, carefully take the pan out.
Place your pizza slices on the pan
Reheat for 10 minutes in your toaster oven.
Take it out and eat it hot.

Reheating Little Caesars Pizza in an Air Fryer

Air Fryers are not really a great option for reheating pizza because you won’t be able to stack slices or reheat a whole pizza. However, they are fast and heat the food thoroughly.

Always defrost your pizza beforehand.
At 400℉, preheat your fryer for 5 minutes.
Place a baking sheet on the bottom and place your pizza slice.
Reheat for 5 minutes and check to see whether the crust is getting crispy.
Take out of the Air Fryer and enjoy.

Steps to Heating up Little Caesars Pizza on a Pan

Some of you might think reheating Little Caesars pizza on a pan is an unusual idea. But that’s how they are made in the first place. You can also reheat it on a pan if you don’t have any other kitchen appliances. That’s what we want to show.

Take a skillet or a non-stick pan.
Place it on the stove. The heat should be medium-high.
Once the pan heats up, place your pizza slices.
Add some grated cheese on top.
Heat the pizza slices for a few minutes.
Add olive oil and a few drops of water around the pan. It will help retain moisture and create a crispy bottom. Don’t put it on the pizza, though.
Close the skillet or pan with a lid immediately. It will create steam to heat the upper part of the pizza.
Take off the pizza from the stove once the cheese has melted.
Serve it after cooling it a bit.

Reheating Leftover Little Caesars Pizza in the Microwave

The problem with microwaves is that they can be tricky when reheating dough. If you are not careful, the bread can get hard or soggy. Then, it will just be a waste. We don’t think reheating pizza in a microwave is better than the other methods.

Defrost your pizza and place it on a microwave-safe plate.
To retain moisture, you can use a damp towel to cover the pizza or a microwave-safe mug filled with water to keep inside the oven along with the pizza.
Heat it for 45 seconds or 1 minute to avoid making the dough rock hard.
Check for any cold spots.
If you find cold spots, reheat it again for 15 seconds.
Take it out and brush butter or olive oil on the crust.
Enjoy your pizza hot.

Tips for all Methods : To always have great reheating results, add grated cheese on top and some olive oil or butter on the crust. You can also reheat your pizza on a plate made with aluminum foil if you don’t have a pizza stone.

What is the Best Way to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza?

Now, you know the top 5 ways to reheat Little Caesars’ pizza. Each is different from another and will give different results in the reheating process. But what is the best way to reheat pizza to yield the best results?

top view of little caesars pizza — Image credit: CBS News

To make things easier, we have a table with all the pros and cons of the five methods. Just go through it and choose your preferred one. However, we will also tell you our favorite way at the end.

Oven	Air Fryer	Microwave	Toaster Oven	Stove
Pros: The oven gives you a crispier, fresher pizza after reheating.	Pros: You will get a crispier crust with minimum time and effort.	Pros: Reheat without minimum effort and in a couple of seconds.	Pros: It is excellent for single or double pizza slices. It doesn’t heat your whole kitchen.	Pros: Stoves will give you a crispier bottom, and the cheese will melt nicely.
Cons: It takes time to preheat and will leave your kitchen feeling very hot.	Cons: You can fit only one or two pizza slices. It will also leave a mess behind.	Cons: It can make your pizza soggy, dry, or hard. You may later also find it bland.	Cons: You can’t heat an entire pizza for guests. It will take a little time to preheat.	Cons: Your bottom crust may get burnt, and the top part may not warm up properly.

Our Verdict: We think the best way to reheat Little Caesars’ pizza is the oven. It is convenient to reheat slices or a whole pizza. It will give you a crispier and fresher pizza, making you feel like you just got it from Little Caesars. You have the convenience of adding extra cheese or toppings if needed. There is no way of burning the pizza while you are busy doing other things. Although it has some downsides, like the preheating time and raising the kitchen’s temperature, we think the results are worth it.

Which Little Caesars Food Items Go Best with Their Pizza?

Little Caesars Pizza has many great pizza options. They have stuffed crust, deep dish, specialty, and classic pizzas, which are all so delicious. But, can we please appreciate their other menu items that go great with their pizzas?

What do you think? Which other items complement their pizzas? Well, we have our own favorites, and maybe you will love them too. Here are our two favorite bread items from the Little Caesars Pizza menu.

1. Italian Cheese Bread Little Caesars

Italian Cheese Bread is a customer favorite of Little Caesars Pizza. The bread is soft with incredible flavors of garlic, butter, Parmesan, Mozzarella, and Muenster cheese. They also make their Italian seasonings themselves, which gives a burst of fresh flavor. Our favorite part is the crispy edges of the bread.

2. Little Caesars Crazy Bread

Little Caesars first started serving their Crazy Bread in 1982, which soon became a hit among customers. They make it by cutting their pizza dough into 8 pieces, and coating it with butter, garlic-infused salt, and Parmesan cheese. It’s a combination of garlic bread and soft, delicious bread.

How to Reheat Pizza in an Oven Normally?

The reheating methods for all the pizzas are the same; it doesn’t matter if it is from Little Caesars Pizza or not. Just choose the kitchen appliance that you have at home that is convenient for you and get reheating leftover pizzas.

Try any of our five methods to reheat your pizza; it will work wonderfully. We have no other advice for reheating, but we have some “what not to do” you might be interested in.

What Not to Do When Reheating Pizza

Wrap it with aluminum foil in the oven. It will make the pizza soggy.
Reheating pizza without defrosting it. It will make the pizza distasteful and will leave cold spots.
Too much heat, like 400 degrees Fahrenheit, is unsuitable for reheating pizza.
Don’t heat pizza in the microwave for a longer time. The pizza will get dry and hard.
Don’t heat your pizza with the plastic wrap still on it. The plastic will just melt into the pizza. We know it’s a weird suggestion, but these things happen.
Never touch a pizza stone empty-handed. It will immediately burn your hand.
Do not use aluminum foil when reheating pizza in the microwave. The microwave will spark and burst into flames.
You should never use any other plates other than oven-safe or microwave-safe plates.

Can You Put a Pizza Box in the Oven?

No, you mustn’t put a pizza box in the oven unless you want a fire. Pizza boxes are not capable of handling heat more than 400 degrees Fahrenheit. After that, they will likely catch on fire, creating a massive fire and needing help from the firefighters.

Moreover, even if you set the oven at a lower temperature, there is the possibility of contamination. Pizza boxes are made of cardboard and glue. We also must not forget that the box is then printed using inks and has an anti-grease layer.

When you reheat the pizza in the pizza box, the anti-grease layer and the gas from the glue get into your food. It will then cause health issues and ruin the pizza in general.

We advise you not to reheat or even store your pizza in the box to avoid any health risks or fire hazards.

Want Directions to Little Caesars Pizza Now?

Little Caesars Pizza is a great hangout spot with budget-friendly items. If you want good pizza and a great time, from our personal experience, we can say it is the best place.

Just go to your nearest Little Caesars Pizza and order as much as you want. Now that you know all the reheating methods for Little Caesars pizza, you can have leftover pizza anytime you want. We hope our methods helped you. Leave us a comment sharing your experience. Have a fantastic day!