Last Updated: May 30, 2022

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream? Tips & Precautions

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream

When reheating leftovers, we are often faced with one major problem. How do you deal with the cold ingredients on foods such as nachos, burritos, or even food wraps? 

What do you do with the layers of sour cream? Can you warm up sour cream in the first place?

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream?

The short answer is Yes, you can! But there are many things you need to be careful about when heating sour cream, whether on its own or whether with leftovers. Most importantly, remember to be gentle and patient. 

Before you go about heating your sour cream, you must know the types and varieties of sour cream available in the market. The type you use will determine the process of your heating and the results you’ll get.

Types of Sour Cream:

  • Full fat sour cream – Typically has a fat content of at least 18% milk fat content.
  • Reduced-fat or low-fat – This variation of sour cream has 25% less milk fat content than proper full fat sour cream. This is the one you typically find in the market.
  • Fat-free variation – Fat-free versions are usually not suitable for baking/cooking purposes. Fat-free sour cream is most susceptible to curdling and forming lumps when heated.

You need to remember that the lower the fat content of your sour cream, the riskier it is to heat it. Sour cream curdles very easily. It is important to be aware of which variety you’re using.

You may also like: How Long Does Sour Cream Last

Is It Safe to Consume Sour Cream?

Sour cream is usually safe to consume, even when heated. If you choose to microwave your sour cream, it is most likely safe to consume.

However, if your sour cream is warm because it has been sitting at room temperature for more than 2-3 hours under high temperature, it is best to not consume it and throw it away.

If the sour cream was exposed to a temperature of more than 90 degrees Fahrenheit for a longer period of time, the fermented cream will spoil and develop harmful pathogens. 

So can you eat warm sour cream then? Well depends on your preferences, really. If you are someone who wouldn’t mind some warm sour cream in your reheated leftover food, go for it. If, however, the thought of warm sour cream makes you feel gross, you can always scrape it off before reheating your food. Add cold sour cream once your food is warm!

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream Using A Microwave?

Leftover food is not the only thing that calls for heating your sour cream. Many lip-smacking recipes require you to add warm sour cream. This is why you should probably know how to microwave your sour cream.

Whether you need to add a spoonful of sour cream to a delicious bowl of soup, or whether you want to cream things up by adding a dollop of sour cream to your favorite casserole- or your mac and cheese recipe! – What you need to look out for is to avoid curdling your sour cream.

Everything you need to know about Warming Sour Cream safely
Everything about Warming Sour Cream (Tips & Precautions): In a Nutshell

Microwaving your sour cream can be very easy if you remember the following tips:

  • Do not microwave your sour cream in a plastic container. It is best to use BPA-free/microwave-safe containers.
  • Don’t heat a large quantity at once. Always go with a few tablespoons in a batch. This way, even if it curdles, you don’t have to throw away the whole batch.
  • As a rule, never use a high-temperature setting and take 15-second intervals between microwaving your sour cream. Stir it occasionally.
  • If your sour cream ends up with lumps, it has already curdled. It is safe to eat but may affect the texture of your dish. It is best at this point to start with a new batch.
a bowl of sour cream
Image credit: Shutterstock

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream In Leftovers? 

Let’s be honest, no one likes to have a burrito that is piping hot and has no cold ingredients for texture. Yes some of us like to scrape off the sour cream and add it later, but sometimes it is impossible to do so. 

At these difficult times, you can either just heat your sour cream along with other ingredients, or add some more cold condiments later. 

But as a general rule of thumb, if you know that your leftovers are filled with sour cream and you’re gonna have to reheat them together, avoid high-temperature heating at all costs. 

Be slow and gentle, and avoid microwaving your leftovers in this case. Prefer reheating methods like an oven or a skillet which will provide a more gradual and even heating exposure.

Furthermore, never heat sour cream that has already been reheated once. You will just end up with bad-tasting leftovers.

You may also like: Can You Microwave Cookie Dough

Can You Warm Up Sour Cream With Other Ingredients? 

First things first, NEVER add cold sour cream to warm ingredients. Always let it come to room temperature first. If you do that, there’s a pretty strong guarantee you’ll curdle and separate the cream by doing so.  

And to answer your question, yes you can. Lukewarm sour cream is used in many curries, soups, and even pasta recipes. 

To prevent your chances of spoiling the sour cream, here are a few precautionary measures:

  • Try tempering your sour cream instead of directly adding it to your dish. For this, gradually add a tablespoon of your hot ingredient to the sour cream to slowly raise its temperature. 
  • To be on the safer side, add a tablespoon of flour to your sour cream and then pour the mixture into your gravy. The flour will act as a binding and thickening agent and also prevent your sour cream from separating.
  • As a rule, keep a track of the temperature of your dish before mixing in the sour cream. It should be under 180 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • Always add sour cream at the very end of your recipe. 

You may also like: How to Reheat Mcdonald’s Nuggets

Uses Of Warm Sour Cream

Now that you know how to heat your sour cream, and what not to do, let’s have a quick look at all the uses of warm sour cream.

  • Soups
  • Mac and Cheese and other Pasta dishes
  • Gravies and Curries
  • Casseroles
  • Entrees such as Beef Stroganoff
  • Dessert sauces like caramel, chocolate, and others.

Don’t be fooled. Sour cream has a lot more uses than being your standard dips or condiments. You can check out this recipe for all your leftover sour cream queries and more!

FAQ

Can you warm up sour cream on the stove?

Sour cream is more likely to curdle and separate on the stove than in the microwave. This could affect the appearance and texture of your dish.

Why does my sour cream curdle when I microwave it? 

You’re likely heating too much sour cream at a time and at a higher than required temperature. Heat in small batches, take regular breaks and stir once in a while.

Is curdled sour cream safe to consume?

Fortunately, yes. Curdled sour cream does not affect the taste or the quality of your dish. It is completely safe to consume. The only downside is it could affect the appearance of your cream.

Can you thaw sour cream in the microwave?

Yes, you can. Be sure to take a 15-second interval between microwaving it though.

Final Thoughts

Can you warm up sour cream? Yes. Is it safe to consume when warm? Also yes! 

I know it can be intimidating to heat your sour cream while also desperately hoping that you don’t accidentally spoil it. But all it takes is some practice! Once you set your hand overheating it right, you can add your creamy, delicious sour cream to so many dishes. It will definitely be worth it! Now that you know how to do it, don’t wait, go try it!

Leave a Comment